Successful practices

For the second year in a row, the Northwest region experienced the fewest workplace injuries of any hospital-based region in Kaiser Permanente. The Northwest ended the 2011 reporting year with a 15 percent improvement over injury rates in 2010. (The two California regions, Hawaii and the Northwest operate hospitals, while Colorado, Georgia, the Mid-Atlantic States and Ohio do not.)

Workplace Safety Committee co-leads Marilyn Terhaar and Susan McGovern Kinard attribute the region’s success to several factors:

• Real-time information. Terhaar sends safety alert emails to managers, stewards, UBT co-leads and safety champions. The alerts list the injuries for the prior week and offer safety tips and resources.
• Goals at the frontline. Keeping injury rates low is a regional goal and a PSP goal. Unit-based teams are encouraged to work on these workplace safety issues prior to tackling other goals.
• Culture change. Safety conversations have become part of the workplace culture. If an employee sees someone not working safely or a hazard in the work area, she or he speaks up, knowing the problem will be addressed.
• Investigation. The approach to safety is proactive. The Employee Health and Safety department investigates the root cause of an accident and tries to make sure the accident does not happen again.

High cost to both employees and KP

Employee injuries are significant in several ways. An injured employee may lose pay and time at work, and a department may have to work short, which may impact patient care. And there’s a financial impact on the organization—which eventually could affect member premiums.

 “The cost to open a workers’ compensation claim is about $1,200 on average,” says Terhaar. “Once you start adding in medical and surgical costs, the expenses can soar.”

Indemnity claims—those claims that cover employees with more serious injuries that require a longer time off—average $21,000.

 “That’s one of the reasons we have such a laser focus on safe patient handling. The risk to the employee for injury is so great,” explains McGovern Kinard.

Prevention

The Northwest region employs a well-constructed safe patient handling program. New employees are trained on safe patient handling, and more than 1,000 employees were retrained in 2011. Hospital and clinic policies require staff to move patients using safe handling techniques and equipment.

 “We have mobile lifts and overhead lifts at Kaiser Sunnyside Medical Center and will have the same equipment at our new hospital opening next year,” says Paulette Hawkins, RN, a workplace safety consultant. “In addition, all medical and dental clinics have mobile lifts and receive annual hands-on refresher training on request.”

Members of the workplace safety committee aren’t resting on their laurels. This year, they plan to bring the focus of safety to the UBT level.

“Most teams can solve their own issues,” say McGovern Kinard. “There’s been an increase in awareness that’s been growing steadily over the last five years. Our numbers say it all.”

For nearly a year now, the Neonatal Intensive Care unit at the Fontana Medical Center has welcomed parents 24 hours a day, thanks to a unit-based team that put the patients’ needs first.

Since April 5, 2011, parents have been able to stay on the unit with the newest member of the family regardless of the hour and even during shift changes and rounding.

“The belief in family-centered care is put into action here,” says management co-lead Annette Adams, RN. “Nothing should come between parents and babies.”

Team members put themselves in the shoes of the parents whose children are treated on the unit: The distress of having a newborn baby staying anywhere other than right by your side, of having to leave your baby in the hands of strangers, and being told when you could come and see your own child.

Making it better for parents

Keeping the service point on the Value Compass in mind, the team looked inward to tackle the problem of concerned parents lacking 24-hour access to the unit.

The UBT began by researching what it takes to have successful open visitation in the NICU and what the benefits are for members and patients. The team found that many NICUs were not truly open to parents 24 hours a day, as parents were asked to leave during change-of-shift reports and physician rounds.

The UBT concentrated on how to make sure parents could remain, despite the concerns.

Shift reports are done at the bedside. But the NICU is one big room where anyone can hear anything. Team members researched how to solve this problem by asking how other Los Angeles-area NICUs, such as Cedars-Sinai Medical Center, handle shift reports without compromising privacy.

Involved in shift hand-offs

Not only do parents now get to see their babies whenever they desire, they are also asked to participate when the physicians round and during the change of shift hand-off, which gives them the opportunity to meet the nurse assuming care of their baby.

“The belief that family-centered care is an essential part of each family’s experience was the driving philosophy behind the progressive move in visiting policy,” says Sheila Casteel, RN, the NICU team’s labor co-lead and UNAC/UHCP member.  

The representative team members enlisted help from the rest of the unit by introducing the concept through the monthly staff newsletter and giving presentations at staff meetings.

Unit staff members were asked for their ideas about how to overcome barriers—real and perceived. Some of the practices adopted included:

• moving the staff hand-off huddle outside the unit to the conference room
• making the relief and admitting nurse available to answer parent questions during hand-offs

Although Rahul Nayak, MD, calls himself “fundamentally lazy,” it might be more accurate to call him lazy like a fox. Instead of starting from scratch to create Georgia’s centralized Outpatient Safety Net Program, his team started with a recipe provided by Southern California.

“Someone has already done something that works. Why not start there?” says Dr. Nayak, who was physician program director of patient safety for Georgia when the program launched.

Dr. Nayak’s outlook serves as the guiding force behind spread—the art of adopting a practice, workflow or project from another team, medical center or even an entire region. The benefits? As the Georgia team learned, new initiatives often get off the ground faster if they’re modeled on an already proven concept. The Southern California safety net system had already won a 2012 David M. Lawrence Patient Safety Award for its work.

“The foundation was laid,” says safety net team member Eula Maddox, LPN, a member of UFCW Local 1996. Maddox makes up to 60 calls a day, phoning members who have had abnormal lab results and scheduling follow-up appointments. “These calls reduce stress for patients and costs for Kaiser Permanente,” she says. But, she notes, the team had to adapt the program for it to work well for Georgia members, including changing the hours that calls were made.

For its work, the team won the 2014 David M. Lawrence Patient Safety Award in the transfer category—an award for a region that successfully implements a project from an earlier award winner. The award recognizes the importance of spreading best practices, which ensures that members receive the same high level of care regardless of which medical center they visit. That’s a primary principle of One KP, which sets the goal of providing every health plan member with “the best experience, everywhere, every time.”

“Our members and customers believe—rightfully so—that we know how to operate as one organization,” says Bernard J. Tyson, KP’s chairman and CEO, “and that whatever we learn about the best ways to care for people in one geographic area…is available to all of our 9.6 million members.”

Best practices occur at all levels and in all departments. In Colorado, for example, the Regional Lab unit-based team tackled the issue of standardizing labels. Even a simple mistake—putting a label on crooked—can adversely affect patient care. The team is creating visual aids and tip sheets that will spread to 28 locations by this fall.

“This is a problem people have had to deal with for years and are passionate about fixing,” says Beth Fisher, a medical technologist, member of UFCW Local 7 and sponsor for the regional lab team.

Spreading practices takes effort from both sides. At Virginia’s Burke Medical Center, a project launched by the Primary Care team four years ago has sustained its success in helping patients with hypertension get their blood pressure under control—and the team has helped other facilities in Northern Virginia adopt the practice.

“If it works for us, it will work for other people,” says the Burke team’s lead nurse, Angela N. Williams-Edwards, RN, a UFCW Local 400 member. “Other teams saw it was easy and ran with it.”