Winter 2013

Colorado

When the Minor Procedures department at the Franklin Medical Office added three surgeons to its staff, the impact was positive: Access improved—patients got in faster. But staff members noticed the new surgeons were using $20 to $30 more in dressings and drapes than surgeons who had been in the department longer. The physicians responded positively when shown the information and, while allowing for medically justified exceptions, have standardized their usage of soft goods so it is more cost effective.

Georgia

The Oncology/Infectious Disease staff at the Cumberland Medical Office Building embarked on a medication reconciliation project to keep patients safe and avoid unnecessary hospital admissions. A manual cleanup of patient records came first. To check the accuracy of the records, medical assistants and licensed practical nurses, all members of UFCW Local 1996, called patients and asked them to bring their medications (or a list) to their next appointment. Providers deleted duplicates and worked across clinical disciplines and with pharmacy colleagues to sustain and improve the process. In just three months in 2011, the percent of duplicate medications fell to 15 percent, which translates to $90,000 saved by reducing hospital admissions.

Hawaii

The nurses in the 23-bed Mother/Baby unit at Moanalua Medical Center learned a lesson in human nature when they placed life-saving emergency airway kits—essential for keeping a weak infant's airways unobstructed—at each bedside. Individual parts of the kits come in handy in other procedures and regularly turned up missing. Keeping everything in zippered plastic bags with a “do not remove” sign didn’t do the trick. But after the team started re-purposing breast pump kit bags--which are sturdier and have labels with room to list the kit’s contents, whether an item has been used and if it’s been replaced—the team went from 75 percent of beds with fully stocked kits to 100 percent in four months.

Mid-Atlantic States

The Adult Primary Care UBT in Falls Church, Va., is using the New Member Identifier tool in KP HealthConnect as the basis for targeted welcome letters and phone calls to set up appointments with primary care physicians and help refill prescriptions. And, when a new member comes in, he or she is provided with a new member kit and offered a one-on-one facility tour. Patient satisfaction percentile scores have risen from 84.6 in the first quarter to 87.4 in the third quarter. Cassandra Hodziewich, MD, a family practice physician, says more new members “are getting needed labs (and) screenings."I think it’s made a difference in the quality of their care."

Northern California

Santa Clara Medical Center showcased its performance improvement work in October to eight UBTs from five regions as part of a two-day LMP learning lab. Visiting the Cardiovascular ICU, the delegation learned how the team uses visual boards to share improvement ideas and track projects. The Pharmacy department explained how it used Six Sigma to reduce workplace hazards, and the Women’s Clinic department outlined its use of process mapping to reduce lab errors. On returning home, the visitors were tasked with finding ways to implement some of what they learned.

Northwest

The Primary Care Team B staff at the North Lancaster Medical Office feels especially strongly about the importance of detecting colorectal cancer early, when it’s highly treatable, since some of their own providers have suffered from the disease. The team, which presented a poster at the Institute for Healthcare Improvement conference in December, tracks who’s eligible for a Fecal Immunochemical Test (FIT) kit, makes sure those members get one, and follows up if the kit isn’t returned. And staff members tell patients how early detection made the difference for their co-workers. The return rate is now 85 percent, up from 50 percent. “We add a personal touch by telling our story,” says labor co-lead Bill Waters, a medical assistant and SEIU Local 49 member, “and people respond.”

Ohio

The Parma Internal Medicine UBT has had a host of successes in its journey to becoming a high-performing team. In addition to improving meetings by defining roles and responsibilities, it has ensured sponsor support and increased staff engagement by creating sub-committees to work on projects. One of its innovative tests of change? Team members decided that while continuing to reduce actual wait times, they would work on the perception of time that patients experience while waiting—and created a slide presentation. The slideshow plays on computers in exam rooms and features health information on chronic diseases.

Southern California

The Bonita Primary Care unit-based team in San Diego, which was included in a poster presentation at the annual Institute for Healthcare Improvement conference, set out on a four-month blitz to reduce its supply expenses by 10 percent, or about $4,750. The team agreed to decreased minimum levels of stock and made diagrams of shelves with new quantities. Staff labeled bins and removed, combined and organized the excess stock, and then used the excess as the primary source for exam room restock over the next four months. As a result, fewer supplies were stocked in exam rooms, fewer supplies were ordered and less stock expired (which would have needed to be replaced). In five months, the team saved nearly $24,700.

I am reminded of the old joke about the holiday ham:

A young bride is preparing her first holiday ham as her adoring husband watches. She slices off one end of the ham and sets it aside and puts the remainder in her roasting pan. “Darling,” her husband asks, “why did you lop off the end of the ham?”

“Why—I don’t know. My mother always did,” she replies. Curious, they call her mother, but her answer echoes her daughter’s: “My mother always did.”  When grandma is called, she has the same answer.

Happily, great-grandma is still on the scene. Her answer to the question is quick: “Why,” great-grandma says, “so it will fit in the pan!”

The obvious point being that sometimes we need to question whether old routines still serve us well. A more subtle point for anyone involved in improving performance is to recognize a workaround for what it is. The more than 3,500 unit-based teams at Kaiser Permanente have daily opportunities to question “the way we’ve always done it.” And as team members become skilled at problem solving and create a culture where asking questions is encouraged, they can create systemic solutions to recurring problems.

In these and other ways, they will create more efficient, cost-effective and safer ways to deliver quality health care. It is essential work, as the cover story of this issue, “Affordable Health Care for All,” makes clear. And the work already is well under way: Every story in the Winter 2013 issue if Hank highlights a different way that teams are improving quality while working to keep Kaiser Permanente affordable.

Kaiser Permanente is the model for the future of health care. Check out this issue's stories and be inspired.

The next step for UBTs—a step they are being challenged to take by top management and union leadership—is to make the leap from successful individual team projects to a systemic effort to implement proven practices throughout the organization.

Meantime, remember another bottom line: High-performing teams score more favorably on People Pulse questions related to efficiency and cost reduction, and high-performing teams are more likely to take on affordability projects.

Working with your colleagues to become a high-performing team is a sure step toward reducing waste and improving affordability. Being high performing will help Kaiser Permanente continue to assist and care for families and will help us ensure everyone has affordable health care.

Here are some ways that unit-based teams can help keep Kaiser Permanente affordable.

1: Build business literacy

The more teams know about the business of health care in general and of their own departments specifically, the better equipped they are to find savings. To that end, LMP’s Education and Training department is rolling out an economic literacy program in the coming year. Meantime, teams in both California regions have been using a curriculum developed by a multidisciplinary team in Northern California. The five-part course has caused some trepidation, since in the last two trainings teams go through their department’s budget line by line—but that’s exactly what gives the training its juice.

At the Fremont Medical Center in Northern California, the OR team took the training and instantly started looking for ways to save money. Co-leads Yolanda Gho, Operating Room nurse manager, and surgical tech Gus Garcia, an SEIU UHW steward, talk about the training, its benefits and how it inspired their team to do better. (For more on this team, click the Peer Advice link in the resources box.)

2: Be supply savvy

Teams that take the time to make a comprehensive assessment of their supplies—tracking inventory use, tidying up storage areas, streamlining ordering and so on—can save tens of thousands of dollars with hardly any pain.

For instance, the scientists in the Immunology department at Southern California’s regional reference lab use expensive chemicals, called reagents, to test whether patients have serious infections such as hepatitis and HIV. Cleaning out and meticulously organizing the department’s huge walk-in refrigerators allowed the team to order larger quantities of reagents at one time. Since employees have to test a sample from each shipment, fewer shipments mean fewer tests—saving staff time and expensive reagent. The work, which also means the team needs fewer rush shipments, is saving $50,000 a year.

Another example comes from the Head and Neck Surgery UBT at the Franklin Medical Office in Colorado, which kept trying small tests of change until it found a reliable way to prevent the disappearance of expensive surgical tools. Contracting with outside individuals or companies often is more expensive than having the same thing done in-house. “In-sourcing” can range from health education centers in Northern California using KP-produced pamphlets instead of costlier items from an outside company, saving $64,000, to the Ohio region opening new micro-clinics so patients in the suburbs can see KP physicians instead of non-Permanente providers. (For more on this team, click "Losing Streak Ends for UBT" in the resources box.)

3: Bring it home

Contracting with outside individuals or companies often is more expensive than having the same thing done in-house. “In-sourcing” can range from health education centers in Northern California using KP-produced pamphlets instead of costlier items from an outside company, saving $64,000, to the Ohio region opening new micro-clinics so patients in the suburbs can see KP physicians instead of non-Permanente providers. (For more on the Ohio region's work, click on "Micro-Clinics, Macro-Partnership" in the resources box.)

4: Collect the money we’re owed

Health care in general and Kaiser Permanente in particular is filled with mission-driven people. But KP can’t sustain its mission if we don’t collect the money we’re owed.

In Colorado, the Medicare Risk Business Services UBT members spotted and fixed a technical problem with incomplete physician signatures on patient charts, which allowed them to bring in more than $10 million in Medicare revenue that otherwise never would have been collected. In Santa Rosa, Calif., the patient services representatives in the Emergency Room analyzed data and did some role playing with one another to reduce discomfort about asking for co-payments.

Figuring out issues like these takes tenacity, as the Patient Financial Services team in the Mid-Atlantic States discovered when it set out to fix problems with workers’ compensation claims. (For more on this team, click "Closing a Financial Gap" in the resources box.)

Jeff and Sara Simmons describe themselves as a “pretty average, middle-class” family living in a Northern California suburb with their sons. “We live a Lego life with two boys,” laughs Sara, describing her toy-strewn living room.

But eight years ago, Sara was diagnosed with Type 1 diabetes, thrusting her into a routine of checking her insulin, monitoring her diet—and paying steep bills for medication and medical equipment. Recently, 7-year-old Owen also was diagnosed with the disease. And the family has to plan for the possibility that 5-year-old Griffin might be diagnosed with it as well.   

Even though the family has medical insurance with Kaiser Permanente, the new bills related to Owen’s care overwhelmed them. They applied for help from one of KP’s medical assistance programs, which helped tide them over until they could get a handle on their new reality.

In the months since, the Simmonses have made some tough choices—deciding, for example, to sell their home and move to an area with a lower cost of living. But Jeff, a manager in a major corporation, worries about how families with lower incomes and fewer health care benefits than his would have fared under similar circumstances.

“How do they do this?” he wonders. “How are they surviving all of these curveballs?”

Health care is “absolutely not” affordable for most people, he says—then adds, “Everybody should have affordable health care. Period.”

A difficult equation

The passage of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act in 2010 was a major step toward ensuring all Americans have access to health care. As provisions of that act take effect in 2014, Kaiser Permanente will have an extraordinary opportunity to further our historic mission of providing affordable, high-quality health care to working families. But with the opportunity comes a difficult financial reality. Because these incoming new members may not have had access to health care in the past, they may be costly to treat—and federal reimbursements may be on the low side. In addition, the federal government has recently cut the rates for Medicare reimbursements, which typically have provided about one-third of KP’s revenue.

So Kaiser Permanente and unit-based teams face the challenge of treating more—and perhaps sicker—patients with fewer resources while maintaining and increasing the quality of care. Now more than ever, allocating our resources wisely is vitally important.

Frugal power

It’s easy to see how departments with multimillion-dollar budgets play a role in keeping KP affordable. For example, National Facility Services kept an eye on potential energy savings when a new data center was built and saved about $450,000 in electricity costs in 2010 and earned a $300,000 incentive from the local utility company. Another example: KP saved $26 million in 2010 alone by buying safer and more environmentally friendly industrial chemicals. And a redesign of the way KP deploys computer workstations saved $12 million as of August 2011.

But unit-based teams have just as big a role to play, even if most don’t control huge budgets. The fact that there are more than 3,500 UBTs across the organization means savings can add up dramatically.

Some teams are saving “light green dollars,” focusing on efforts that indirectly improve the financial picture. That might be boosting service and quality, which helps us get new members and retain the ones we have, or improving patient safety, which reduces a variety of expenses, including costly hospital readmissions.

Others are tackling “dark green dollars,” direct savings that improve the bottom line right away. In fact, efficiency and non-payroll cost reduction is the fastest-growing category of projects for teams, according to an analysis of UBT Tracker data.

Is your team looking for new ways to save light or dark green dollars—or in need of ideas to get started saving? Read Four Ways to Save.

Fremont’s Operating Room team loved taking the first parts of Northern California’s business literacy training—so much so, it immediately requested the last two sessions, when teams pull out their budgets to review line-item expenses for the department. The review of payroll and non-payroll budgets has caused controversy and concern in some quarters, but the Fremont OR team not only took it in stride, it rode the momentum of the training by developing several performance improvement projects to reduce waste. One of those, streamlining its ready-made surgical supply packs, is projected to save roughly $34,000 a year. The Northern California training began rolling out in 2011. The first three sessions are a tutorial on the basics of Kaiser Permanente business, explaining such things as our integrated business model (how the various KP entities do business together), key sources of revenue, and business concepts like margin goals. The rubber meets the road in the final two sessions, with their look at the department’s financial realities. Team co-leads Yolanda Gho, Operating Room nurse manager, and Gus Garcia, a surgical technologist and SEIU UHW steward, talked with communications consultant Cassandra Braun about the training, its benefits and how it inspired their team to do better.

Q & A

Q. Were you concerned about sharing the department’s payroll and non-payroll budget with staff?

Gho: Not really. I thought, “Why don’t we highlight the areas where we have opportunities to improve, like sutures—ones we can improve on and have control over.” With payroll, my one concern was showing someone’s salary. But it was explained that they didn’t show individuals’ salaries. So I was totally on board.

Q. What was the staff’s reaction to the training?

Gho: The response was quite eye-opening. There was an audible gasp. When they saw [the red lines], they were like, “Oooh, I thought we were doing great. Why do we have all that red on the screen?” What’s great about this group is their minds immediately started running, thinking about what they could do.

Garcia: To me, it’s like: We can fix that, or come up with ideas (for fixing it). That is what melds it all together.

Q. Talk about your project to streamline surgical packs and how it was influenced by the business literacy training.

Garcia: Surgical packs have draping and supplies for each particular procedure. They’re ready-made. So you always had to add things or throw away things that you didn’t want, depending on the procedure. I was trying to see what we need or don’t need. I worked with the supplier and our teams, like general surgery, and I asked their opinion—“What do you need in this thing and what do you not need?” We streamlined the packs to have the bare minimum. So everyone uses everything in the pack.

Gho: After the training, Garcia wanted to revisit this issue, because he had brought this up before.

Garcia: The wheels were turning in my head. If we’re not using it, we’re wasting money.

Q. You also started work on reducing waste of sutures and other supplies?

Gho: Yeah, it was a culture change. In the past, as a nurse or tech, you were trained to always be ready. You were trained that the surgeons shouldn’t have to ask for something. Some people think that if they’re able to do that, they’re seen as efficient and anticipating the needs. But the world is different, the economy is different. Now we have to ask ourselves, “Do we need to have this open to look good or just in case a surgeon asks for it? Or is it OK not to open it, but to have it in the room and ready?” Before, we were all trained that way—anticipate, anticipate, anticipate. We now give ourselves a centering moment before we open sutures or supplies that are not needed immediately for a case.

Q. What advice would you give to other teams thinking about taking business literacy training?

Gho: My advice is to help educate your staff members by being transparent about information that affects them and the team. As a manager, I want to create awareness and understanding of the issues with my staff. It bridges the information and knowledge gap. The more we’re armed with information, the better decisions we make.

Garcia: If it was up to me, I’d have everyone take the class. I think it just gives you a different perspective. It breaks it down and gives you an overall view that staff members don’t get to see all the time. It keeps them informed.

Gho: People tend to complain about things but do nothing about it. In our UBT, you bring solutions. We’re doers. It’s our chance to do something.