Coalition of Kaiser Permanente Unions Concepts

Louise Dempsey is the business representative for UFCW Local 1996 in Atlanta. She spoke with LMP communications consultant Laureen Lazarovici about her experiences as a union activist in the South.

In the late ’60s and early ’70s, my mom worked for the Social Security Administration. She transferred often for her job, so we moved a lot. She was in the union, and she organized two of the offices she got transferred to in order to get better benefits. One was in the hills of Tennessee, where there were a lot of coal mines and a lot of poverty. She once worked for a group of attorneys and mobilized her co-workers to get better wages. There was a lot of disparity in pay in terms of gender and race. Sometimes, they didn’t exactly like her. She earned the reputation as the go-to person. People would say, “If anybody can get it done, it’s Mildred.”

Unions at Kaiser Permanente

And today, here we are in the South. It is not strong union territory. Because of Georgia’s so-called “right to work” law, employees can work for KP here whether they join the union or not [in contrast to KP regions in other states with stronger worker protection laws]. But people join because they know that the stronger we are, the more we can stand up for ourselves. We have to talk to folks about the benefits of working for a unionized company. I worked for KP as an LVN before there was a union. Our wages were all over the place and assignments were based on favoritism. We’ve had people come to work for KP because it’s unionized.

When they hear about the Labor Management Partnership, they say, “I’ll sign up.” They understand they have a voice, they can be part of a UBT, they can affect the direction their team is going, and say what they need and want and be heard. Sure, we have to educate managers, but we have to educate employees about unions, too. When I talk at new employee orientation, I tell them we are there as a mediator, facilitator, advisor. You are not by yourself anymore. I’ve got your back and your front and your side, too. With the Labor Management Partnership, KP is always offering opportunities for employees to learn, like the Ben Hudnall Memorial Trust. I have been in the medical field for 30 years, and folks are always thirsting for more knowledge.

Getting used to a new way of doing things

Folks in management come into Kaiser and they are not used to unions or the partnership. We have to educate them: We have a union, we have a contract, we have a partnership. We educate them about a union environment and also that we are not the traditional head-butting adversarial union.

Normally, when I go into a meeting at KP, there is not a whole bunch of posturing. People want to get to a solution. There is no name-calling, finger-pointing or yelling. It makes a difference. Partnership benefits the local because I have open access to the employees. I went to five facilities recently. I was not stopped once. It is always, “Hi, how are you, who do you need to see?” My co-workers at the local who represent employees at other companies don’t all have that. KP has not relegated me to a break room or to certain hours. I can have a bulletin board in the break room. I have the time to speak with new hires during orientation. They don’t censor the questions the employees ask or the ones I answer. That’s partnership.

Do corporate leaders understand the lives of working people? Some do. In the long history of Kaiser Permanente, several executives—including Henry J. Kaiser himself—worked their way up from poverty. Clifford Keene, MD, was another. In a 1985 interview, he described his roots:

“I came from a very humble family. My father was a factory foreman at best....During the summer I always worked. I sold papers or worked in factories doing minor tasks. Then, when I was fourteen I went to work in the steel industry as a steel construction punk, an apprentice first....I would find myself doing construction all over western New York State. I became a connecter; that is, a person who gets up on the steel and puts it together. I became accustomed to being up in the air and being up high, although I was always frightened of being up in the air. I don't think anyone is not frightened when you're way up in the air and the steel moves. It's a situation that commands your respect and gets your attention, I can tell you. I earned quite good money and continued to do that until I was a sophomore in medical school.”

The experience stayed with him throughout his life. He reflected on it when commenting on a successful infant bowel surgery while serving as a cancer specialist at the University of Michigan State Hospital at the end of the 1930s:

“When I was in the army I further developed my interest in bowel surgery, and reconstruction of all kinds, and also in plastic procedures, orthopedic procedures, all of which were an extension of my interest in doing things with my hands. I [had been] a steel worker* and it was satisfying to correct things with my hands.”

Fremont’s Operating Room team loved taking the first parts of Northern California’s business literacy training—so much so, it immediately requested the last two sessions, when teams pull out their budgets to review line-item expenses for the department. The review of payroll and non-payroll budgets has caused controversy and concern in some quarters, but the Fremont OR team not only took it in stride, it rode the momentum of the training by developing several performance improvement projects to reduce waste. One of those, streamlining its ready-made surgical supply packs, is projected to save roughly $34,000 a year. The Northern California training began rolling out in 2011. The first three sessions are a tutorial on the basics of Kaiser Permanente business, explaining such things as our integrated business model (how the various KP entities do business together), key sources of revenue, and business concepts like margin goals. The rubber meets the road in the final two sessions, with their look at the department’s financial realities. Team co-leads Yolanda Gho, Operating Room nurse manager, and Gus Garcia, a surgical technologist and SEIU UHW steward, talked with communications consultant Cassandra Braun about the training, its benefits and how it inspired their team to do better.

Q & A

Q. Were you concerned about sharing the department’s payroll and non-payroll budget with staff?

Gho: Not really. I thought, “Why don’t we highlight the areas where we have opportunities to improve, like sutures—ones we can improve on and have control over.” With payroll, my one concern was showing someone’s salary. But it was explained that they didn’t show individuals’ salaries. So I was totally on board.

Q. What was the staff’s reaction to the training?

Gho: The response was quite eye-opening. There was an audible gasp. When they saw [the red lines], they were like, “Oooh, I thought we were doing great. Why do we have all that red on the screen?” What’s great about this group is their minds immediately started running, thinking about what they could do.

Garcia: To me, it’s like: We can fix that, or come up with ideas (for fixing it). That is what melds it all together.

Q. Talk about your project to streamline surgical packs and how it was influenced by the business literacy training.

Garcia: Surgical packs have draping and supplies for each particular procedure. They’re ready-made. So you always had to add things or throw away things that you didn’t want, depending on the procedure. I was trying to see what we need or don’t need. I worked with the supplier and our teams, like general surgery, and I asked their opinion—“What do you need in this thing and what do you not need?” We streamlined the packs to have the bare minimum. So everyone uses everything in the pack.

Gho: After the training, Garcia wanted to revisit this issue, because he had brought this up before.

Garcia: The wheels were turning in my head. If we’re not using it, we’re wasting money.

Q. You also started work on reducing waste of sutures and other supplies?

Gho: Yeah, it was a culture change. In the past, as a nurse or tech, you were trained to always be ready. You were trained that the surgeons shouldn’t have to ask for something. Some people think that if they’re able to do that, they’re seen as efficient and anticipating the needs. But the world is different, the economy is different. Now we have to ask ourselves, “Do we need to have this open to look good or just in case a surgeon asks for it? Or is it OK not to open it, but to have it in the room and ready?” Before, we were all trained that way—anticipate, anticipate, anticipate. We now give ourselves a centering moment before we open sutures or supplies that are not needed immediately for a case.

Q. What advice would you give to other teams thinking about taking business literacy training?

Gho: My advice is to help educate your staff members by being transparent about information that affects them and the team. As a manager, I want to create awareness and understanding of the issues with my staff. It bridges the information and knowledge gap. The more we’re armed with information, the better decisions we make.

Garcia: If it was up to me, I’d have everyone take the class. I think it just gives you a different perspective. It breaks it down and gives you an overall view that staff members don’t get to see all the time. It keeps them informed.

Gho: People tend to complain about things but do nothing about it. In our UBT, you bring solutions. We’re doers. It’s our chance to do something.

Cutting waste and saving money for Kaiser Permanente members and patients is good. But 350 Environmental Service workers in Southern California are taking that mission a step further by tending to Mother Earth as well.

Kaiser Permanente and two Labor Management Partnership-funded workforce development trusts are among the health care partners nationwide that are training frontline workers and managers in improved recycling, waste disposal, energy conservation and other green practices. The U.S. Department of Labor and the Healthcare Career Advancement Program, a national partnership of unions and hospitals, are leading the effort.

“‘Carbon footprint’ is a phrase that’s thrown around a lot,” says Milford “Leroy” Alaman, EVS operations manager at the Los Angeles Medical Center. “Now our staff is able to understand that when you are talking about conserving energy, water and electricity, you are talking about looking at the resources we have in our facility and holding on to just what we need instead of creating more waste for us and the planet.”

Leading change at work

Along the way, these “green teams” also are reducing operating costs, enhancing employee skills and morale, and improving patient and workplace safety. 

For example, the EVS department is now using environmentally friendly microfiber mops to clean a single patient room. This has the benefit of not spreading infections between rooms and preventing lifting and straining injuries caused by wringing traditional mops and hauling buckets of water.

The department also has started a project that is reducing the cost and trouble of replacing the 500 D-cell batteries used in the hospital restrooms’ automatic towel dispensers. The traditional batteries wore out in a matter of weeks—costing about $3,000 a year to replace and adding some 6,000 batteries a year to local waste or reprocessing streams. Starting in February 2012, workers installed new rechargeable batteries. Overall, EVS' green projects, including the use of rechargeable batteries, are saving an estimated $12,000 a year.

Enhancing skills, raising sights

“I feel better having conversations with anyone…doctors, nurses, I can tell them how to be green,” says EVS attendant Jose Velasco, an SEIU UHW member and a recent graduate of a green certification course offered at West Los Angeles Community College.

The program also was piloted at KP Riverside Medical Center, where the EVS unit-based team is reaching out to others with its newfound expertise. Now an EVS member is embedded with the Operating Room UBT—with others to follow—to help tackle waste and hygiene problems there.

The SEIU UHW-West & Joint Employer Education Fund and the Ben Hudnall Memorial Trust have helped underwrite the cost of the training for Kaiser Permanente’s LMP-represented workers. Eventually, frontline workers may be able to use their certifications for higher pay and promotions as medical center “green leads,” a program that would be negotiated between KP and the unions.

But the training already is making a difference to workers as well as to KP and the community. “They have more tools, more knowledge, so they are able to catch things,” says Angel Pacheco, management co-lead of the EVS UBT at Riverside. “We talked about saving the environment for future generations.”

When Webster Parker brought his prescription glasses back to the clinic in Redlands (Southern California), he thought he just needed to replace a lens that had fallen out. But when Parker reported his eye was watering excessively, optician Alicia Rendon spotted a red flag in Parker’s Kaiser Permanente HealthConnect™ record and, within the hour, set up an eye-saving appointment with an ophthalmologist.

“The prescription was fine,” says Rendon, a Teamsters Local 166 member whose unit-based team recently embraced a new workflow, including use of KP’s electronic health record system, to troubleshoot their redos—instances where patients return eyewear purchases. “Once I looked into HealthConnect, there was this big stop sign.”

Her review of the record suggested that Parker, 85, might need a common surgical procedure to lower the intraocular pressure in his right eye, a condition often associated with glaucoma. An old eye injury exacerbated the problem, and Parker’s ophthalmologist had set up a flag in the system to watch for changes to the eye.

“I had surgery that week,” says Parker, a retired pharmacist who once ran a drugstore with his pharmacist wife. “The eye feels better. It feels normal. They did a wonderful job.”

Looking at the whole system

Focusing on redos not only saves KP in terms of the cost of materials and labor but also helps improve service scores. By bringing in ophthalmologists and optometrists, who examine eyes to treat disease as well as prescribe the lenses that opticians dispense, the team could better identify redos linked to eye-health problems rather than product defects—as in Parker’s case.

But opticians, used to handling paper charts and focusing on frame styles, were reluctant to try one of the team’s first tests of change: using KP HealthConnect to rule out medical reasons for unsatisfactory eyeglasses.

“We got buy-in” to overcome the initial resistance, says management co-lead Darren Smith, site supervisor for optical dispensing and a former optician. “It takes just two or three to really commit and spread the practice. Now, it’s not just a retail store where you come and buy something. Here, we are talking about your health.”

Educating patients and staff

To protect patient privacy, opticians' access in HealthConnect was mostly limited to conditions related to eyeglasses' prescriptions rather than a broader range of eye issues. Now the optometrists and ophthalmologists help the optical UBT members spot problems and counsel patients on practices that will protect their eyesight and enhance their eye care.

“Not everyone is going to be able to see 20/20,” says Trissy Bastin, business line manager for Vision Essentials. She directs the service area’s five optical clinics and serves as sponsor for the UBT. “The patients have to be reminded of that. You have to be able to see what kind of eye conditions they have.”

Parker has been a KP member for just seven years. But three decades in the health care industry fostered his appreciation for the electronic patient record—and cooperation and coordination among caregivers.

“What makes Kaiser special is that any doctor can have your complete record at his fingertips,” Parker says. “They can track problems and make recommendations.”